Calling member function of number literal

I'm trying to call literal functions, but I get weird behavior.

Consider this code which returns true.

   23 === (23)

When I write try the following.


I get the expected result _23.00_ but when I try 23.toFixed(2) I get this error.

SyntaxError: Unexpected token ILLEGAL

How does JavaScript evaluate expressions that cannot understand this and why do I get this error?



The answers by Greg Hewgill and icktoofay are correct in all ways, however, I'd like to get down a bit, abstraction-wise: Let's see what's really happening according to the javascript specification.

Section 7.8.3 of the spec defines numeric literals. We can see the following:

DecimalLiteral ::
    DecimalIntegerLiteral . DecimalDigits(opt) ExponentPart(opt)
    . DecimalDigits ExponentPart(opt)
    DecimalIntegerLiteral ExponentPart(opt)

DecimalIntegerLiteral ::
    NonZeroDigit DecimalDigits(opt)

A DecimalLiteral, a number, is a bunch of decimal digits, possibly followed by a dot, which is possibly followed by other digits (all of which can be followed by an exponent, e12 for instance). In other words, 42. is legal and equal to 42 and 3e2 is equal to 300.

Note how if we have a dot, we either expect it to be followed by more digits/exponent, or be followed by nothing. However, and this is the important part, the dot is part of the number. Remember this as we move to look how the dot operator, obj.prop, is dealt with.

Section 11.2.1, Property Accessors describes the dot and bracket notation for member access:

MemberExpression . IdentifierName

CallExpression is for function calls, which we don't care about. Notice how we're expecting a MemberExpression (which can be a DecimalLiteral - but don't take my word for it, look and see whether I'm right).

See that little dot? It's logical to jump forward and say "well, there's a dot in the scheme here...and there's a dot in why is there an error?" Alas my hypothetical friend whom I use for these sentences, you forgot how the DecimalLiteral looks like! Let's go over two examples and see what happens.

The caret represents the character we're on. So far, we're inside DecimalLiteral / DecimalIntegerLiteral / NonZeroDigit (that's quite a mouthful). Let's move to the next character:

Still part of the number, a perfectly valid DecimalDigit.

ok, so we're out of the DecimalIntegerLiteral part. Here's the same diagram on the scheme:

DecimalIntegerLiteral . DecimalDigits(opt) ExponentPart(opt)

So we're on a dot, which is a perfectly valid part of a number. Now we consume it, as part of the number, and move on:

f is neither part of DecimalDigits nor of ExponentPart, we're out of the number now. So...what now? What's that f? It's not part of anything. Maybe it's a property accessor? Let's take a look at the scheme:

MemberExpression . IdentifierName

We're definitely on MemberExpression, but we don't have a dot which follows it - that dot is already part of the number. We've reached a syntactical error: we stop execution and throw it. Hopefully you don't live in a glass house.

Hopefully now you understand why works. Once we're out of the MemberExpression, we face another dot:

MemberExpression . IdentifierName

Followed by a perfectly legal IdentifierName.

Of course, there're several other ways to separate the dot from the number. One way, as you showed, is to surround the literal in parentheses: (42).foo. When we've reached the parentheses end, we're out of the MemberExpression, and on the dot. Another way is to insert a space: 42 .foo, since a space can't be part of the number, and it's neutral for the parser, so it won't raise an error.


Unlike Ruby (for example), The Javascript parser considers a . following digits to be part of the number. So the parser sees the tokens:

23. toFixed ( 2 )

which is a syntax error, because the word toFixed immediately following a floating point number doesn't make sense. A language such as Ruby that accepts this syntax would see the following tokens:

23 . toFixed ( 2 )




Is that the floating-point literal 5. or an integer 5 followed by a dot? You don't know; it's ambiguous. JavaScript takes the former view. In JavaScript's view, you've got a floating-point literal followed by an identifier (then followed by a left parenthesis, number, and a right parenthesis).

Some people work around this by using two dots:


Since a floating-point literal can only possibly have one decimal point, the other dot is a literal dot token.


Recent Questions

Top Questions

Home Tags Terms of Service Privacy Policy DMCA Contact Us

©2020 All rights reserved.